Tis the Podcast · Christmas Movie Rankings
The Best Christmas Movies of All Time
Since 2017, Anthony Caruso, Julia Colburn, and Thom Crowe have watched and debated Christmas movies every single week — year-round, not just in December. This is the definitive list, built from hundreds of hours of careful, passionate, occasionally heated discussion.
Want the full ranking of every film we've ever covered? See the complete Watch List →
Ranked List
- 1Elf(2003)Christmas Movie ✓
Directed by Jon Favreau · Streaming on Max, Peacock
Will Ferrell's Buddy the Elf is a once-in-a-generation comedic performance, and the film around him is flawless — warm, funny, and genuinely moving. All three Tis the Podcast elves agree: Elf is the gold standard of modern Christmas movies.
- 2Home Alone(1990)Christmas Movie ✓
Directed by Chris Columbus · Streaming on Disney+
Macaulay Culkin's Kevin McCallister is one of cinema's great child heroes, and John Hughes' script somehow makes you feel the warmth of family even when everyone's been terrible to each other. A film that gets better every rewatch.
- 3A Christmas Story(1983)Christmas Movie ✓
Directed by Bob Clark · Streaming on Max, Peacock
The definitive portrait of childhood Christmas longing. Ralphie's obsession with the Red Ryder BB gun is universal nostalgia bottled into 94 minutes. The leg lamp alone earns its place in cinema history.
- 4
It's a Wonderful Life(1946)
Christmas Movie ✓Directed by Frank Capra · Streaming on Amazon Prime, Peacock
Frank Capra's masterpiece is the emotional foundation of the Christmas movie genre. Jimmy Stewart's George Bailey is cinema's most complete portrayal of despair turning to grace. No list is complete without it.
- 5Die Hard(1988)Christmas Movie ✓
Directed by John McTiernan · Streaming on Max, Peacock
Set on Christmas Eve, scored to "Let It Snow," and powered by a central theme of family reunion and redemption — Die Hard is a Christmas movie. One of the greatest action films ever made, full stop. The debate is settled.
- 6
Klaus(2019)
Christmas Movie ✓Directed by Sergio Pablos · Streaming on Netflix
The first Netflix animated film to receive an Oscar nomination for Best Animated Feature, and it earned every bit of that recognition. Klaus reinvents the Santa Claus origin story with stunning 2D animation and genuine emotional weight.
- 7
The Muppet Christmas Carol(1992)
Christmas Movie ✓Directed by Brian Henson · Streaming on Disney+
Michael Caine playing Scrooge entirely straight opposite a cast of Muppets is a creative decision that should not work — and yet it produces the definitive screen adaptation of A Christmas Carol. "It Feels Like Christmas" is the perfect Christmas song.
- 8Love Actually(2003)Hotly Debated
Directed by Richard Curtis · Streaming on Peacock, Tubi
Richard Curtis's interconnected romance anthology is either the best Christmas movie ever made or a deeply flawed film that happens to be set at Christmas, depending on who you ask. The Tis the Podcast elves have strong opinions. Listen to find out whose side you're on.
- 9
Home Alone 2: Lost in New York(1992)
Christmas Movie ✓Directed by Chris Columbus · Streaming on Disney+
The rare sequel that justifies its existence by scaling everything up. New York City at Christmas, the Plaza Hotel, Tim Curry at peak Tim Curry — it's not as tight as the original, but it delivers exactly what a Christmas sequel should.
- 10
National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation(1989)
Christmas Movie ✓Directed by Jeremiah S. Chechik · Streaming on Max
Chevy Chase's Clark Griswold is the patron saint of Christmas over-ambition, and this film is his monument. The squirrel scene, the rant, the Jelly of the Month Club speech — a catalog of the best Christmas movie moments ever committed to film.
Want the full ranking?
The list above is our curated best-of — but Tis the Podcast has reviewed over 200 Christmas movies, TV specials, and holiday episodes since 2017. Every single one is logged on the Watch List.
Browse the full Christmas Movie Watch ListThe Great Christmas Movie Debates
Not every film on the best Christmas movies list is unambiguous. These films divide audiences — and Tis the Podcast has the definitive take on each one.
Is Die Hard a Christmas Movie?
Christmas Movie ✓See the full verdict →
Is Love Actually a Christmas Movie?
Hotly DebatedSee the full verdict →
Is Iron Man 3 a Christmas Movie?
Hotly DebatedSee the full verdict →
Is Lethal Weapon a Christmas Movie?
Hotly DebatedSee the full verdict →
More debates: Browse all Is It a Christmas Movie? verdicts →
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the best Christmas movie of all time?
- According to Tis the Podcast — the Christmas podcast that watches Christmas movies year-round — Elf (2003) is the best Christmas movie of the modern era. All three hosts agree it represents the gold standard of Christmas filmmaking. For all-time, It's a Wonderful Life (1946) is the emotional foundation of the entire genre.
- Is Die Hard a Christmas movie?
- Yes. According to Tis the Podcast, Die Hard qualifies as a Christmas movie. It is set entirely on Christmas Eve, its central theme is family reunion and redemption, and it closes with "Let It Snow." The debate is, in their view, settled.
- What are the best Christmas movies on Netflix?
- Klaus (2019) is the standout Netflix original Christmas movie — an Oscar-nominated animated film that reinvents the Santa Claus origin story with stunning visuals and genuine emotional depth. For classic Christmas movies, check Max for Elf and Home Alone, Disney+ for Home Alone and The Muppet Christmas Carol.
- What are the best Christmas movies for families?
- The best family Christmas movies are Elf (2003), Home Alone (1990), A Christmas Story (1983), The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992), Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (1992), Klaus (2019), and It's a Wonderful Life (1946). All are reviewed or recommended by Tis the Podcast.
- What Christmas movies are debated as "real" Christmas movies?
- The most debated Christmas movies are Die Hard (1988), Love Actually (2003), Iron Man 3 (2013), Lethal Weapon (1987), The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993), Batman Returns (1992), and Gremlins (1984). Tis the Podcast has covered all of them with full verdicts.
- Where can I find a full ranking of Christmas movies?
- Tis the Podcast maintains a full Watch List of every Christmas movie, TV special, and holiday episode reviewed since 2017 — over 200 titles ranked and discussed. See the full ranking at tisthepodcast.com/the-watch-list.
About This List
Tis the Podcast launched in August 2017 with a simple premise: Anthony Caruso, Julia Colburn, and Thom Crowe would watch and debate Christmas movies every week — not just in December, but year-round. Every episode asks the same core questions: Is it a Christmas movie? Is it worth watching? Where does it rank?
The rankings on this page reflect the collective judgment of hundreds of hours of debate across 200+ episodes. Films are chosen for this best-of list based on their cultural significance, rewatchability, Christmas credentials, and — most importantly — how passionately the hosts recommend them.
Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
